統合時の整合性と残る制約

Source SHA-256 39ea52825948373a7cee3e1539a8411f892827d5ba9323d8c4d36f9f52288f4d

LATEST_CHECKPOINT: INT-PUB-FINAL-026

INTEGRATION_READINESS_AUDIT-INT-022: final gate census grants CONDITIONAL_CLEARANCE_FOR_ASSEMBLY. IR-001/002/005/006/007/008 are closed or non-blocking under their existing canonical-input and layer-separation controls. IR-004 current-byte linkage is closed at 8/8; historical-byte equality and undocumented persisted-result transformations remain disclosed UNKNOWNs. IR-003 no longer blocks bounded assembly when the 20-month study is cited only through archived Crossref/Zenodo artifact facts and article-prose-dependent statements are omitted or marked unresolved; exact article span remains RECOVERY_ACTIVE. The single editable DOCX, fail-closed preflight, render and readback are the remaining publication-blocking gate. FUEL_SLICE_COMPLETE; next exact item is PUBLICATION_ASSEMBLY_MANIFEST and the first integrated DOCX.

PREVIOUS_CHECKPOINT: INT-C05-EU-021

LATEST_CHECKPOINT: INT-C05-EU-021

INTEGRATION_READINESS_AUDIT-INT-021: the EU Article 14 current-status gate is closed for text identity, authoritative amendment, consolidation role and application dates. The authentic 2024 OJ byte snapshot remains canonical; Regulation (EU) 2026/1744 supplies the in-force applicability change; the consolidated display is non-authentic documentation. Publication must state the 2027/2028 split and Article 2/111 boundaries, not the stale general 2 August 2026 date. Remaining gates are the 20-month article exact span, disclosed historical/serialization UNKNOWNs and final integrated DOCX/render/readback. FUEL_SLICE_COMPLETE; next exact item is a final publication-gate census.

PREVIOUS_CHECKPOINT: INT-PROV-REV-020

LATEST_CHECKPOINT: INT-PROV-REV-020

INTEGRATION_READINESS_AUDIT-INT-020: the Frozen SOURCE_REVISION correspondence is closed for the registered source document's current snapshot. Docs documents.get returned the exact opaque revision ID in Work_STATE; Drive revisions.list for the same file returned current revision 58; revision 58 fetched successfully; prior text equality remains recorded. The opaque ID stays canonical, and no general cross-revision conversion is inferred. No Core, Product Mapping, Organization or empirical-origin change. FUEL_SLICE_COMPLETE; next exact item is EU AI Act current-consolidation applicability.

INTEGRATION_READINESS_AUDIT-INT-019: IR-004 current-byte provenance linkage is closed at 8/8. The final permission-memory result has canonical path, Library identity, exact size, full SHA-256 and direct ledger links; its embedded fixture/runner hashes match inputs with existing full historical digest matches. The result itself lacks a prior digest, and its compact JSON schema is not verbatim runner stdout, so historical equality and transformation provenance remain UNKNOWN. No test was rerun. FUEL_SLICE_COMPLETE; next exact item is Frozen opaque revision correspondence with Drive revision 58.

INTEGRATION_READINESS_AUDIT-INT-018: IR-004 historical raw residual count is reduced from three artifacts to one for current-byte provenance linkage. The OpenFGA runner/result have canonical paths, Library identities, exact sizes, full SHA-256 values and direct ledger links. The result retains an abbreviated historical digest match; runner historical equality remains UNKNOWN. The result is an enriched persisted record rather than verbatim stdout, and transformation provenance is explicitly UNKNOWN. No test was rerun. FUEL_SLICE_COMPLETE; next exact item is tests/CORE-02_permission_memory_fixture_rerun_2026-09-05.json.

INTEGRATION_READINESS_AUDIT-INT-017: IR-004 historical raw residual count is reduced from six artifacts to three for current-byte provenance linkage. The Mem0 SQLite history runner and Qdrant runner/result now have canonical paths, Library identities, exact sizes, full SHA-256 values, result-anchor locators and direct ledger links. Historical equality remains UNKNOWN for the two runners; the Qdrant result preserves its recorded abbreviated match. No test was rerun. FUEL_SLICE_COMPLETE; next exact cluster is the OpenFGA runner/result pair.

INTEGRATION_READINESS_AUDIT-INT-016: IR-004 historical raw residual count is reduced from eight artifacts to six for current-byte provenance linkage. The CORE-01 JavaScript validator and JSON fixture now have canonical path, Library identity, exact byte size, full SHA-256 and direct audit/collection/question links. Their historical digest equality remains UNKNOWN, and no rerun occurred. IR-003 remains open for the 20-month article exact VOR/accepted-manuscript span; current publisher/API access failure is not an absence finding. FUEL_SLICE_COMPLETE; next exact item is tests/CORE-02_mem0_history_reset_live_v0.2.py.

INTEGRATION_READINESS_AUDIT-INT-015: the second S050 OSS observatory example is publication-locator ready with archived-repository identity, commit, Git blobs, local hashes and line locators across README and implementation/workflow files. IR-003 no longer depends on either S050 OSS observatory example; it remains open for the 20-month article exact VOR/accepted-manuscript span and other provenance residuals. Archived historical implementation and committed outputs are not current or independent effectiveness evidence; same-weight divergence does not identify its cause. FUEL_SLICE_COMPLETE; next exact item is DOI 10.1016/j.scico.2026.103530 authorized article span, then the first historical raw digest/linkage residual if access remains blocked.

PREVIOUS_CHECKPOINT: INT-C06-S050-014

INTEGRATION_READINESS_AUDIT-INT-014: the first S050 OSS observatory example is publication-locator ready with commit, Git blobs, local hashes and line locators across README and implementation files. IR-003 remains open for russsi/llm-drift-observatory and other provenance residuals, not for egnaro9/model-drift. Implementation availability is not independent effectiveness evidence; live board claims, weight identity, causal attribution and Organization acceptance remain outside the closed scope. FUEL_SLICE_COMPLETE; next exact item is russsi/llm-drift-observatory from S050 lines 102–106.

PREVIOUS_CHECKPOINT: INT-C06-S050-013

INTEGRATION_READINESS_AUDIT-INT-013: Log Probability Tracking is publication-locator ready with ICLR/arXiv v2 bytes, exact page ranges, author-linked implementation identity and hashes. IR-003 remains open for the two S050 OSS observatory examples and other provenance residuals, not for this paper. Ground-truth-free field detections, logprob availability and non-causal method limits remain visible. FUEL_SLICE_COMPLETE; next exact item is egnaro9/model-drift from S050 lines 102–106.

PREVIOUS_CHECKPOINT: INT-C06-S050-012

INTEGRATION_READINESS_AUDIT-INT-012: GateScope is publication-locator ready with paper bytes, exact page ranges, author-linked implementation identity and hashes. IR-003 remains open for subsequent S050 observability originals and other provenance residuals, not for GateScope. The evidence is explicitly bounded to a client-side framework and 10 anonymized gateways; named-provider/current/universal/internal-cause and Organization conclusions remain UNKNOWN. FUEL_SLICE_COMPLETE; next exact item is arXiv:2512.03816.

PREVIOUS_CHECKPOINT: INT-C06-S050-011

INTEGRATION_READINESS_AUDIT-INT-011: S050 line 91 is bibliography- and replication-artifact-ready, not article-span-ready. Crossref fixes identity; Zenodo fixes study window, test items, metrics and disclosed aggregates. IR-003 stays open for exact paper span. No causal hidden-backend, universal/current provider or Organization inference. FUEL_SLICE_COMPLETE; next GateScope arXiv:2604.21083 unless a direct authorized manuscript appears.

PREVIOUS_CHECKPOINT: INT-C06-S050-010

INTEGRATION_READINESS_AUDIT-INT-010: the Chen/Zaharia/Zou S050 drift source is publication-locator ready: peer-reviewed final release, DOI, local bytes, exact spans, and author-repository identity are fixed. IR-003 remains blocked by the later S050 drift/observability originals and other provenance residuals. The article does not close universal/current provider drift, backend identity or Organization values. FUEL_SLICE_COMPLETE; next exact item is S050 line 91, ScienceDirect PII S0167642326000961.

PREVIOUS_CHECKPOINT: INT-C06-S050-009

INTEGRATION_READINESS_AUDIT-INT-009: the first CORE-06 S050 original-source cluster is closed with an exact Drive-revision S050 snapshot and pinned Phoenix/MLflow author-repository files, hashes, commits/blobs and line locators. IR-003 remains publication-blocked by the remaining S050 drift/observability sources and other provenance residuals, not by versioned-evaluation linkage. Acceptance decision remains this study's synthesis. FUEL_SLICE_COMPLETE; next exact item is the S050 model-drift cluster beginning with Chen/Zaharia/Zou.

EARLIER_CHECKPOINT: INT-C07-ARCHIVE-008

INTEGRATION_READINESS_AUDIT-INT-008: LiveBench arXiv v2 and author-repository README source-byte gates are closed with hashes, page/line locators and commit/blob identity. IR-003 remains publication-blocked by remaining CORE-06 S050 original-source links and other provenance residuals, not by the LiveBench archive. Universal contamination resistance, present cadence, current-provider validity and Organization acceptance remain UNKNOWN. FUEL_SLICE_COMPLETE; next exact item is CORE-06 S050-contained original links.

PREVIOUS_CHECKPOINT: INT-C05-ARCHIVE-007

INTEGRATION_READINESS_AUDIT-INT-007: EU Article 14 authentic OJ and OR-Bench PMLR source-byte archival gates are closed with hashes and page locators. IR-003 remains publication-blocked by LiveBench and other original-source/archive gaps. EU current-consolidation applicability, benchmark current-provider validity and Organization acceptance remain UNKNOWN. FUEL_SLICE_COMPLETE; next exact item is LiveBench.

PREVIOUS_CHECKPOINT: INT-C05-ARCHIVE-006

INTEGRATION_READINESS_AUDIT-INT-006: HAI and AWS source-byte archival gates are closed with publisher PDFs, hashes and page locators. IR-003 remains publication-blocked by EU Article 14, OR-Bench, LiveBench and other original-source/archive gaps. Human effectiveness and live idempotency stay UNKNOWN. FUEL_SLICE_COMPLETE; next exact cluster is EU Article 14 + OR-Bench.

PREVIOUS_CHECKPOINT: INT-C05-ARCHIVE-005

INTEGRATION_READINESS_AUDIT-INT-005: the source-byte archival gate is closed for OWASP Lies-in-the-Loop and ADK issue #6732 only. Hashes and supporting locators are registered. IR-003 remains publication-blocked because HAI, AWS, EU Article 14, OR-Bench, LiveBench and other original-source/archive gaps remain. FUEL_SLICE_COMPLETE; next exact cluster is HAI camera-ready PDF + AWS idempotency article.

PREVIOUS_CHECKPOINT: INT-C05-PRIMARY-004

INTEGRATION_READINESS_AUDIT-INT-004: six separate external primary locator bindings (NIST/EU/ADK) across CORE05/07; NIST PDF archived. Core unchanged. Current applicability/empirical universality UNKNOWN. Prior pointers below superseded; NEXT = archive remaining verified external source bytes, then CORE06 S050-contained original links. No repeat of completed locator checks.

CONTINUED_CORE05: COL-C05-005 OWASP and COL-C05-006 HAI direct locator checks, COL-C05-004 AWS direct locator checks complete; four external relation rows. Stripe current substantive text insufficient. NEXT_EFFECTIVE: CORE05 COL-C05-003 NIST/EU original spans and COL-C05-007 ADK issue version/claim bounds; then pending external archives and CORE06 S050. Do not repeat completed CORE05 OWASP/HAI/AWS locator checks.

This supersedes the next-item pointer below, not the retained history. CORE07 direct internal spans are now bound for all 12 claims, with partial-support limits; CORE06-007 also has its S045 direct span. Five section snapshots match the fetched revision58 content. INT-PROV-REV-020 verifies that the registered Frozen opaque ID and Drive revision58 identify the same current snapshot; the opaque ID remains canonical. Two external abstract checks are separate from the internal design evidence. No Core claim wording changed.

IR-001/002/005/006/007/008 retain the saved structural disposition in INT-SOURCE-RECOVERY-002. IR-003 remains PUBLICATION_BLOCKED, not closed by 70/70 structural coverage or 15 new internal bindings. IR-004 retains 18 recovered artifacts and now has 8/8 current-byte linkage for the historical non-full-match set; row-specific historical equality and transformation UNKNOWNs remain distinct. No new missing-file inference.

NEXT_ITEM: CORE05 COL-C05-003..007 original-source spans and snapshots, starting COL-C05-005 OWASP Lies-in-the-Loop; then CORE06 remaining S050 original-source linkage. Preserve recovered raw artifacts; reconcile Library identity/version before merge. Do not redo CORE07 current-version span extraction or the previous routing/PM matrix repairs.

This section supersedes conflicting historical counts/statuses below; history is retained.

No final DOCX clearance. CORE-07 residual direct spans, PM/ORG historical identity reconciliation and remaining source-level provenance must still be addressed. Raw-byte recovery is not an experiment rerun or automatic claim approval.

INTEGRATION_READINESS_ID: INT-READY-001

AUDITED_AT: 2026-09-13T05:03:04+09:00

FROZEN_TOC: S063 v0.1

INPUT_STATE: Work_STATE v94 / BEGIN_GLOBAL_PROVENANCE_INTEGRATION_GATE

STATUS: BOUNDED_AUDIT_COMPLETE / INTEGRATION_BLOCKED / NO_DOCX_BUILD

PERSISTENCE_STATUS: LOCAL_CHECKPOINT_ONLY / REMOTE_WRITE_UNAVAILABLE_THIS_RUN

SCOPE: existing Core packets, provider mappings, Organization Overlays, central registries, local experiment projection and canonical-path consistency only

RECOVERY_CHECKED_AT: 2026-09-13T05:59:38+09:00

RECOVERY_STATUS: AUTHORIZED_DRIVE_EXACT-NAME_CHECK_COMPLETE / 0 OF 22 ARTIFACT IDENTITIES RECOVERED / LIBRARY_CHECK_PENDING

SCHEMA_NORMALIZED_AT: 2026-09-13T06:59:32+09:00

最終統合とDOCX組版は開始しない。Core 7 packetは存在するが、provider/Organization coverage、claim-source relation、raw experiment artifact、中央台帳control header、canonical pathに未解決不整合がある。公開本文へ昇格せず、下記の順で回収・正規化する。

2026-09-13T05:59:38+09:00に、欠落候補4成果物と18 raw test artifactを正確なファイル名で検索した。22件すべてについて同名ファイルは取得できなかった。語を空白区切りにした補助検索では関連するCore・中央台帳・研究通信が返ったが、対象ファイルそのものではなく、raw bytes・digest・独立artifact identityを回収できないため代替証拠として採用しない。

• PM-GEMINI-CORE-01.md: NOT FOUND BY EXACT NAME

• PM-GEMINI-CORE-07.md: NOT FOUND BY EXACT NAME

• ORG-CORE-01.md: NOT FOUND BY EXACT NAME

• ORG-CORE-07.md: NOT FOUND BY EXACT NAME

• 18 raw test paths listed below: 0/18 FOUND BY EXACT NAME

境界：これはauthorized Drive上の検索結果であり、永続正本側に存在しないことの証明ではない。Library接続が復旧するまでLIBRARY_CHECK_PENDINGを維持する。summaryや関連文書からraw artifactを再生成せず、実測claimは該当bytesとdigestが回収できるまでPROVENANCE_BLOCKEDとする。

Counts describe the current local projection. A missing local artifact is LIBRARY_RECOVERY_REQUIRED, not proof that the original was destroyed.

SEVERITY: HIGH

STATUS: BLOCKING

Work_STATE.md states that Gemini/GPT/Claude/Grok CORE-01..07 public mappings are complete. Files exist for GPT, Claude and Grok CORE-01..07, but Gemini files exist only for CORE-02..06. PM-GEMINI-CORE-01.md and PM-GEMINI-CORE-07.md are absent. AUDIT_REGISTER.md explicitly routes CORE-07 work to PM-GEMINI-CORE-07, confirming that the missing identity is not merely an optional filename.

DISPOSITION: search persistent Library/Drive history for the exact two identities. Restore existing artifacts if found; otherwise compile bounded mappings from already-registered evidence without reopening Core research. Do not retain the “all provider mappings complete” claim until both are present and read back.

SEVERITY: HIGH

STATUS: BLOCKING FOR FINAL DOCX

organization_overlays/ORG-CORE-02.md through ORG-CORE-06.md exist. ORG-CORE-01.md and ORG-CORE-07.md are absent, although Core and provider mappings route completion, ownership, thresholds, release authority and live organization values to those overlays.

DISPOSITION: recover or create the two bounded overlays with values left UNKNOWN/NOT_ADOPTED where no authorized evidence exists. Absence must not be represented as a zero-risk or not-applicable value.

INT-REL-C02-C07-001: central structural coverage now 70/70 distinct claim IDs, zero missing relation rows. Added 44 synthesis/dependency rows for previously uncovered claims; existing CORE-01 and CORE-06 rows preserved. Explicit external support is separate. This closes missing-row bookkeeping only, NOT publication provenance: source snapshots/exact locators, internal direct spans, and raw experiment recovery remain open. Manifest-only dependencies must not become external citations.

IR-005: current control fields reconciled across four ledgers; historical collection/audit dates retained. IR-006: seven Queue summary rows now route to integration instead of restarting completed provider handoffs, without claiming missing mapping identity is recovered. IR-007: build-input ambiguity resolved by CANONICAL_PATH_MANIFEST.md; remote identity reconciliation remains pending. IR-001/002/004 and full source readiness remain unresolved.

INT-REL-C01-001 (2026-09-13): CORE-01 central relation backfill completed in SOURCE_REGISTRY.md: 10 distinct claims, 20 external/synthesis rows, 14 inherited external evidence records with URLs/version/date/scope. No Core claim changed. Relation coverage is not publication clearance; mutable-source snapshots/exact spans and raw experiment recovery remain open. Prior 25-row/45-gap count below is the historical baseline, not a recomputed unique-claim count. Next bounded unit: CORE-02 uncovered claim relations; do not repeat CORE-01 backfill or IR-008.

SEVERITY: HIGH

STATUS: PUBLICATION_BLOCKING

The seven Core packets contain 70 CLM-C01..07 claim rows. SOURCE_REGISTRY.md contains 25 explicit Core claim relation rows. PROVENANCE_POLICY.md requires every claim to bind CLAIM_ID → ORIGIN_CLASS → EVIDENCE_ID → SOURCE_OR_EXPERIMENT_ID → SUPPORTING_LOCATOR → SCOPE_AND_LIMIT; therefore at least 45 Core claims lack an explicit central relation row. Presence of evidence tables inside packets does not satisfy the central publication gate by itself.

DISPOSITION: backfill claim-source relations Core by Core. Mark incomplete mutable-source locator/digest and experiment metadata as PROVENANCE_BLOCKED or RECOVERY_ACTIVE; do not infer missing fields.

SEVERITY: HIGH

STATUS: READBACK_BLOCKING

Eighteen referenced tests/... paths are not present locally. They include CORE-01 contract/requiredness/mock-integration artifacts and CORE-02 permission, OpenFGA, LlamaIndex/BM25, Mem0 reset/history and dependency-fixed results. Later CORE-02..07 fixtures are present.

DISPOSITION: search persistent Library and authorized Drive records by exact filename and recorded digest. Restore bytes and verify digest before final citation. Until then, affected empirical claims remain LOCAL_PROJECTION_MISSING / LIBRARY_RECOVERY_REQUIRED, not SOURCE_LOST and not publication-ready.

SEVERITY: MEDIUM

STATUS: INTEGRATION-BUILD BLOCKING

AUDIT_REGISTER.md, QUESTION_QUEUE.md, COLLECTION_REGISTER.md and INDEX_DELTA.md still identify a GPT CORE-04-era current cycle in their top control headers, while append-only tails contain Claude, Grok and NotebookLM completions. A generator reading the header can produce a different current state from a generator reading the tail.

DISPOSITION: normalize top headers to an integration cycle and record the latest audit/question/collection/index IDs. Preserve historical append entries; do not rewrite their facts.

SEVERITY: MEDIUM

STATUS: INTEGRATION-BUILD BLOCKING

Compilation_Packet_Queue.md rows 3–7 retain earlier GPT/Claude-era statuses and next actions, although later deltas say all four provider waves are complete. CORE-02 alone has been normalized to all-provider completion.

DISPOSITION: reconcile rows 1–7 from the completed provider artifacts and leave live/Organization residuals explicit. The row table becomes the integration manifest; historical deltas remain audit history.

SEVERITY: MEDIUM

STATUS: INTEGRATION-BUILD BLOCKING

Both root CORE-02.md and packets/CORE-02.md exist with different sizes and SHA-256 values. Work_STATE.md and packet operations use packets/CORE-02.md; the root copy is older. An unconstrained assembler could select the wrong content.

DISPOSITION: designate packets/CORE-02.md as canonical in the integration manifest. Quarantine, alias or remove the root mirror only after persistent identity/history is checked. Do not merge the two blindly.

SEVERITY: MEDIUM

STATUS: LOCALLY_REPAIRED / PERSISTENT_WRITE_PENDING

Five mapping files lack a literal PRODUCT_MAPPING_ID: header: Claude CORE-01, GPT CORE-01 and Grok CORE-01..03. Their identities are inferable from filenames/content, but the final index must not depend on inference.

DISPOSITION: explicit stable PRODUCT_MAPPING_ID fields were added to the five locally present mappings without changing mapping claims. All 27 currently present mapping files now expose the field. Revalidate after persistent writeback and after recovery/creation of the two missing Gemini mappings; the expected 29-file matrix remains incomplete.

• tests/CORE-01_contract_ablation_v0.1.json

• tests/CORE-01_field_requiredness_reaudit_v0.2.js

• tests/CORE-01_field_requiredness_reaudit_v0.2.json

• tests/CORE-01_mock_integration_v0.1.js

• tests/CORE-02_dependency_fixed_local_live_2026-09-05.json

• tests/CORE-02_elcat_rag_diagnostic_fixture_v0.1.js

• tests/CORE-02_elcat_rag_diagnostic_fixture_v0.1.json

• tests/CORE-02_llama_bm25_permission_live_v0.1.py

• tests/CORE-02_mem0_history_reset_live_v0.1.py

• tests/CORE-02_mem0_history_reset_live_v0.2.py

• tests/CORE-02_mem0_qdrant_reset_live_2026-09-05.json

• tests/CORE-02_mem0_qdrant_reset_live_v0.1.py

• tests/CORE-02_openfga_permission_live_2026-09-05.json

• tests/CORE-02_openfga_permission_live_v0.1.py

• tests/CORE-02_permission_memory_fixture_rerun_2026-09-05.json

• tests/CORE-02_permission_memory_fixture_v0.1.js

• tests/CORE-02_permission_memory_fixture_v0.1.json

• tests/CORE-02_pm_live_profile_attempt_2026-09-05.json

• Check PM-GEMINI-CORE-01, PM-GEMINI-CORE-07, ORG-CORE-01, ORG-CORE-07 and the 18 raw test paths in Library when access resumes. Authorized Drive exact-name recovery is complete with 0/22 identities recovered.

• Normalize central registry headers and Queue rows 1–7 from recovered/current artifacts.

• Add the five missing explicit Product Mapping IDs and validate the 29-file mapping matrix.

• Backfill all 70 claim-source relation rows with origin, locator and scope; keep unresolved items blocked.

• Resolve the CORE-02 canonical-path collision.

• Generate an integration manifest and run link/ID/digest readback.

• Only after the above passes, begin editable single-DOCX assembly and render/readback.

LIBRARY_RECOVERY_AND_INTEGRATION_IDENTITY_DECISION: check exact filenames and recorded digests in Library. If the four mapping/overlay identities are confirmed absent, create only those bounded artifacts from already-registered evidence with unknown organization values preserved. Do not reconstruct the 18 raw artifacts from summaries; mark affected empirical claims PROVENANCE_BLOCKED when bytes cannot be recovered. Do not reopen completed Core research or start DOCX assembly.