{ "format": "agent-article-v0", "article_id": "EA-144", "canonical_url": "/tools/ea-144-ibm-watsonx-orchestrate", "page_type": "reference", "claim_ids": [], "evidence_ids": [ "EVD-EA-144-URL-F49DBAED789D", "EVD-EA-144-URL-3CA0E547871D", "EA-144-R11-RESEARCH", "EA-144-R11-WEB-READBACK" ], "unknown_ids": [ "EA-144-UNKNOWN-01", "EA-144-UNKNOWN-02", "EA-144-UNKNOWN-CURRENTNESS" ], "operational_object_ids": [], "provider": [], "models": [], "plans": [], "surfaces": [], "regions": [], "current_status": "UNKNOWN", "observation_status": "SPEC_ONLY", "freshness": "UNKNOWN", "last_verified": null, "supersedes": [], "superseded_by": [], "provenance": [ "COMM-044-EA0144", "SRC-EA-144-URL-F49DBAED789D", "SRC-EA-144-URL-3CA0E547871D", "WEBBODY-EA0144-R8-52AB74AD" ], "article_sources": [ { "id": "EVD-EA-144-URL-F49DBAED789D", "evidence_class": "RESEARCH", "title": "source_class=official product documentation; exact_title=IBM watsonx Orchestrate; author/org=IBM; canonical_url=", "href": "https://www.ibm.com/products/watsonx-orchestrate", "supports": [], "limit": "元の監査済み資料に記載された参照先です。URLの復元は、資料の最新性や全主張の支持を新たに検証したことを意味しません。", "origin_class": "SOURCE_PACKET_REFERENCE", "source_or_experiment_ids": [ "SRC-EA-144-URL-F49DBAED789D" ], "supporting_locators": [ "EVIDENCE_TABLE", "- source_class=official product documentation; exact_title=IBM watsonx Orchestrate; author/org=IBM; canonical_url=https://www.ibm.com/products/watsonx-orchestrate" ], "scope": "EVIDENCE_TABLE", "provenance_status": "SOURCE_PACKET_REFERENCE_PROJECTED" }, { "id": "EVD-EA-144-URL-3CA0E547871D", "evidence_class": "RESEARCH", "title": "source_class=official product/developer documentation; exact_title=AI agent development and deployment; author/org=IBM; canonical_url=", "href": "https://www.ibm.com/products/watsonx-orchestrate/developers", "supports": [], "limit": "元の監査済み資料に記載された参照先です。URLの復元は、資料の最新性や全主張の支持を新たに検証したことを意味しません。", "origin_class": "SOURCE_PACKET_REFERENCE", "source_or_experiment_ids": [ "SRC-EA-144-URL-3CA0E547871D" ], "supporting_locators": [ "EVIDENCE_TABLE", "- source_class=official product/developer documentation; exact_title=AI agent development and deployment; author/org=IBM; canonical_url=https://www.ibm.com/products/watsonx-orchestrate/developers" ], "scope": "EVIDENCE_TABLE", "provenance_status": "SOURCE_PACKET_REFERENCE_PROJECTED" }, { "id": "EA-144-R11-RESEARCH", "evidence_class": "RESEARCH", "title": "EA-144 監査済みresearch / canonical revision binding", "supports": [ "IBM official product/developer materials describe watsonx Orchestrate as an agent-management/control-plane product with agent discovery/connection/orchestration, owners/dependencies/activity/cost visibility, access/policy/guardrails, third-party agent environments, ADK, LangGraph import, tool/API integration, human approval, evaluation/regression testing, and multi-provider AI Gateway capabilities." ], "limit": "canonical監査・revision bindingの存在を示す。外部ソースcurrentnessが本文またはcontrol-planeで確定していない場合は、currentnessをUNKNOWNのまま保持する。", "origin_class": "AUDITED_CANONICAL_RESEARCH_PACKET", "source_or_experiment_ids": [ "COMM-044-EA0144" ], "supporting_locators": [ "COMM-044-EA0144", "EA-144-R5-LEGACY-MIGRATION-20261008-R1", "content/staging/EA-144.md" ], "scope": "監査済みEA本文・canonical revision・既存Source Graph relationの範囲。欠損currentnessは推測で閉じない。", "provenance_status": "AUDIT_PASS_CANONICAL_BINDING" }, { "id": "EA-144-R11-WEB-READBACK", "evidence_class": "IMPL", "title": "EA-144 Web body identity / canonical readback", "supports": [ "canonical staging bodyのSHA-256一致とR9 canonical ledger readbackをProduction projectionの入力として検証する。" ], "limit": "body identity/readbackは本文claim自体の真偽や外部ソースの最新性を追加保証しない。", "checked_at": null, "origin_class": "IMPLEMENTATION_READBACK", "source_or_experiment_ids": [ "WEBBODY-EA0144-R8-52AB74AD" ], "supporting_locators": [ "WEBBODY-EA0144-R8-52AB74AD", "content/staging/EA-144.md", "EA-144-R5-LEGACY-MIGRATION-20261008-R1" ], "scope": "R9/R10 canonical readback後のProduction生成時body identity。", "provenance_status": "CANONICAL_READBACK_BODY_HASH_MATCH" } ], "research_sections": [ { "heading": "WHY_THIS_MATTERS_TO_UPDATE", "text": "複数agentを発見・接続・統合・評価・統治するcontrol planeと、ADK・LangGraph import・AI Gateway・human approvalの製品境界をIBM provider mappingへ更新する。" }, { "heading": "SCOPE_ROUTING", "text": "provider mapping / organization overlay / interoperability / governance / security / audit / cost / operability。" }, { "heading": "CLAIM_OR_RESEARCH_QUESTION", "text": "IBM公式ページがwatsonx Orchestrateのcontrol plane、agent開発経路、multi-provider、approval、evaluation、governanceを何と記載しているか。" }, { "heading": "EVIDENCE_TABLE", "text": "- source_class=official product documentation; exact_title=IBM watsonx Orchestrate; author/org=IBM; canonical_url=https://www.ibm.com/products/watsonx-orchestrate; publication/update/access_date=current product page accessed 2026-09-13 JST; version/release/tag/commit/API revision=current product page（製品version未固定）; supporting_locator=Overview / Features / Discover more AI agents / Govern / Mitigate risk（build/deploy/orchestrate/manage/governするagent management platform、agents/owners/dependencies/activity/cost visibility、access/policy/guardrails、third-party agent environment接続とBedrock agentの取り込み、PII等のrisk policyの記述）; evidence_label=SOURCE_REPORT+PRODUCT_VOLATILE; relation=support+limit\n- source_class=official product/developer documentation; exact_title=AI agent development and deployment; author/org=IBM; canonical_url=https://www.ibm.com/products/watsonx-orchestrate/developers; publication/update/access_date=current page accessed 2026-09-13 JST; version/release/tag/commit/API revision=current product docs; supporting_locator=Build new agents or bring your own / Everything your agents need in production（ADKによるlow-code/pro-code、LangGraph agent import、API/tool integration、human-in-the-loop approvals、evaluation/regression testing、OpenTelemetry/Langfuse、AI Gatewayによるmulti-provider model routingの記述）; evidence_label=VERIFIED_SPEC+PRODUCT_VOLATILE; relation=support+context" }, { "heading": "FINDINGS", "text": "- ESTABLISHED: IBM公式ページは、watsonx Orchestrateをagent管理・control planeとして、agent discovery/connection/orchestration、owners/dependencies/activity/cost visibility、access/policy/guardrails、third-party environment、ADK、LangGraph import、tool/API、human approval、evaluation/regression、multi-provider AI Gatewayを製品要素として記載している。\n- NOT_ESTABLISHED: “enterprise-grade”“production”の製品表現は、全plan/region/tenantでの有効化、import互換、policyの完全阻止、評価の妥当性、SLA・ROIを証明しない。ページの機能存在と利用組織の契約・権限を同一視しない。" }, { "heading": "LIMITS / COUNTEREVIDENCE / FAILURE ENVELOPE", "text": "third-party agent importのversion/API差、AI Gateway routingの誤選択、human approvalの誤承認・race、policy設定漏れ、activity/cost trace欠損、connector side effectが残る。IBMのページ上の機能・case/marketing値は独立再現benchmarkではない。" }, { "heading": "AVAILABILITY_GATES", "text": "IBM契約・plan・region・trial/production、ADK版、LangGraph互換範囲、AI Gatewayとmodel provider、connector/API credentials・scope、RBAC、data isolation、OTel/Langfuse、quota・billing。" }, { "heading": "IMPLEMENTATION_STATE", "text": "IBM official product/developer docs + PRODUCT_VOLATILE。Docs記載の機能存在と導入経路を保存した段階。IBM tenantの設定・認証・外部書込み・課金・本番migrationは未実施。" }, { "heading": "BENCHMARK_OR_EVAL", "text": "公式Docsはevaluation/regression testing機能を記載するが、どのevaluator・dataset・thresholdで、どの業務品質・安全率・costを達成したかは本Packetで確立していない。UNKNOWN。" }, { "heading": "SECURITY / PRIVACY / AUDIT / COST / OPERABILITY", "text": "Security=central policy・RBAC・approval・connector scopeをagent/tool/model別に設定。Privacy=import agent、gateway、memory/trace、外部providerのデータ境界。Audit=owner・dependency・version・activity・approval・policy decision・costを相関。Cost=control plane、model、connector、evaluation、storage、retryを含む。Operability=import compatibility、rollback、policy fail-closed、provider outage、trace completenessを検証。" }, { "heading": "SAFE_WORDING_FOR_FUTURE_BOOK", "text": "「IBM watsonx Orchestrateの公式資料は、複数agentの発見・接続・統合・評価・統治を行うcontrol planeと、ADK／LangGraph import／AI Gateway／human approval等の経路を案内している。機能存在は、契約・plan・region・RBAC・互換性・業務品質・SLAの保証ではない。」" }, { "heading": "UPDATE_WORK_HANDOFF", "text": "IBM provider mappingとorganization overlayへ、control plane・agent import・gateway・approval・evaluation・policyを別claimで渡す。次回はpricing/plan表、region、release、ADK/LangGraph import matrix、RBAC/audit/data isolation、公開incident、実業務evalを補う。" }, { "heading": "OPEN_UNKNOWN", "text": "current product/API release、各plan/region、third-party import parity、AI Gateway routing policy、approval/audit schema、data isolation、pricing、実業務品質・ROI・障害復旧。" }, { "heading": "STOP_CONDITION", "text": "IBM公式の“enterprise-grade”“production”表現を独立保証へ変換しない。agent catalog・control planeの存在からユーザー組織の全agent接続可否を推測しない。\nUNIT_CLOSE_STATUS: INDIVIDUAL_BOUNDED_CLOSE / EVIDENCE_RECORDED / UNKNOWN_PRESERVED\n\n---" }, { "heading": "PUBLIC_CLAIM", "text": "IBM official product/developer materials describe watsonx Orchestrate as an agent-management/control-plane product with agent discovery/connection/orchestration, ADK, LangGraph import, tool/API integration, human approval, evaluation/regression, policy/guardrail controls, and multi-provider AI Gateway capabilities. These product statements do not establish availability for every plan/region/tenant, import parity, policy completeness, SLA, ROI, or production quality." }, { "heading": "ESTABLISHED", "text": "IBM official product/developer materials describe watsonx Orchestrate as an agent-management/control-plane product with agent discovery/connection/orchestration, owners/dependencies/activity/cost visibility, access/policy/guardrails, third-party agent environments, ADK, LangGraph import, tool/API integration, human approval, evaluation/regression testing, and multi-provider AI Gateway capabilities.\n\nNOT_ESTABLISHED:\nFeature and marketing statements do not establish enablement for every plan, region, or tenant; third-party import parity; complete policy prevention; evaluation validity; SLA; ROI; production quality; or organization-specific entitlement." }, { "heading": "LIMITS_FAILURE_ENVELOPE", "text": "Third-party agent import can vary by version/API. AI Gateway routing can be misconfigured. Human approval can be incorrect or race with execution. Policy configuration can be incomplete. Activity/cost traces can be incomplete. Connector side effects remain possible. IBM product/case/marketing statements are not independently reproduced benchmarks." }, { "heading": "AVAILABILITY_GATES", "text": "IBM contract/plan/region/trial-production state; ADK version; LangGraph compatibility scope; AI Gateway/model-provider support; connector/API credentials and scopes; RBAC; data isolation; OpenTelemetry/Langfuse integration; quota and billing." }, { "heading": "SECURITY_PRIVACY_AUDIT_COST_OPERABILITY", "text": "Security: central policy, RBAC, approval, and connector scope must be evaluated per agent/tool/model. Privacy: imported agents, gateway traffic, memory/trace data, and external providers create distinct data boundaries. Audit: correlate owner, dependency, version, activity, approval, policy decision, and cost. Cost: include control plane, model, connector, evaluation, storage, and retry. Operability: verify import compatibility, rollback, policy fail-closed behavior, provider outage handling, and trace completeness." }, { "heading": "BENCHMARK_EVAL", "text": "IBM documentation describes evaluation/regression testing capability, but this packet does not establish evaluator/dataset/threshold choices or achieved business quality, safety rate, or cost. UNKNOWN." }, { "heading": "OPEN_UNKNOWN", "text": "current product/API release; plan/region availability; third-party import parity; AI Gateway routing policy; approval/audit schema; data isolation; pricing; production quality; ROI; incident recovery." } ], "human_url": "/tools/ea-144-ibm-watsonx-orchestrate", "markdown_url": "/agent/article.md?path=%2Ftools%2Fea-144-ibm-watsonx-orchestrate", "json_url": "/agent/article.json?path=%2Ftools%2Fea-144-ibm-watsonx-orchestrate" }